Consumer Auth - Yext Auth Question

Hey team - question on setting up Consumer Auth using Yext auth in the theme. I followed the HH guides and this guide from Rachel’s consumer auth bug bash with SEs. I have the dev console app set up with the Signing Key configured, and I added the auth.json file in Admin Console, added the necessary files in the code editor, and added the yext auth lines to the vertical config JSON. When I open the prod link in incognito, I’m prompted to log in, and I log in as the user. Based on the user config, the user should be able to see the file as set in the access controls param. However I’m not able to get any results to appear. Can anyone advise on why the right files aren’t appearing for this user? Thanks so much!